Is Traderie Legit? Real User Reviews
Discover Traderie, a popular platform where players trade items across top Roblox games like Adopt Me, Royale High, MM2, and Blox Fruits.
Traderie has become one of the most talked-about trading platforms in the Roblox community. Thousands of players use it daily to trade items across popular games like Adopt Me, Royale High, Murder Mystery 2, and Blox Fruits.
They operate differently from traditional marketplaces. It doesn't sell items directly. It connects players who want to trade with each other. This peer-to-peer model creates unique risks.
Let's examine what Traderie actually offers and what real users experience when they use the platform.
What is Traderie?
Traderie is a peer-to-peer marketplace platform designed for video game item trading. The site connects buyers and sellers across multiple games, with a primary focus on Roblox titles like Adopt Me, Royale High, Murder Mystery 2, and Blox Fruits.
The platform also supports trading for other games, including Monopoly GO, Diablo 4, Animal Crossing, Pokémon titles, and various popular Roblox experiences.
Users create listings for items they want to trade. Other users browse these listings and make offers. The platform provides value estimates for items. Users can rate and review each other after completing trades.
Traderie operates through both a website and mobile apps. The platform claims to be a "moderated" marketplace with community features like user profiles, review systems, and reporting tools.
Also Read: Plants vs Brainrots: Complete Rebirth Guide (2025)
How Does Traderie Work?
The Traderie system functions as a middleman connector, not a direct trading platform.
Here's the reality: Traderie doesn't handle the actual trades. The platform simply connects users who want to trade items. All actual item exchanges happen outside Traderie, directly within the games themselves.
The process works like this
Users create an account and connect their Roblox profile to verify identity. They list items they want to trade by selecting from Traderie's database of game items. Other users browse these listings and submit offers through Traderie's messaging system.
When both parties agree on a trade, they coordinate a time to meet inside the actual game. The trade happens through the game's built-in trading mechanics. After completing the trade in-game, users return to Traderie to rate each other.
This is where problems start.
Because Traderie doesn't control the actual trades, scammers exploit the system. They build fake positive reviews. They agree to trades on Traderie. Then they scam users when the actual in-game trade happens. By the time victims report them, the scammer has already moved to a new account.
The platform relies entirely on user reviews to establish trust. But these reviews can be manipulated. Scammers create multiple accounts to inflate their ratings. Real negative reviews get buried under hundreds of fake positive ones.
Also Read: How to Get Shroombino in Plants vs Brainrots (2025)
User Reviews and Community Feedback
Community feedback reveals significant platform issues that extend beyond individual bad trades.
A June 2023 Trustpilot review with a 1-star rating captures the frustration perfectly:
"ENTIRE WEBSITE IS TOTAL TRASH DONT USE IT. NO CUSTOMER SERVICE, REPORTS ARE NOT HANDLED, ITEM VALUES ARE EASILY MANIPULATED, CANT REACH A REAL PERSON TO HANDLE SITUATIONS, ANYONE CAN LEAVE A FAKE BAD REVIEW WITHOUT TRADING, NOTIFICATIONS DONT WORK FOR HOURS AFTER SENT.. WHOLE WEBSITE IS THE WORST RH TRADING SITE EVER!" That wasn’t a minor complaint. This is complete system failure.
Another verified Trustpilot reviewer in May 2025 stated: "The site is very laggy, has a lot of errors/constant glitches, lots of bots and scammers easily bypass and the mods ignore that entirely. The notifications also barely work."
This perfectly captures the technical problems users consistently report. Notice the pattern? Users from 2023 and 2025 report identical problems. Nothing improves.
A May 2025 review exposes the toxic environment: "Stop begging for reviews lol... Also, this site is full of hackers, scammers, rude people, and people who only want massive overpays and get angry if you underpay even slightly..." This reviewer isn't just complaining about scammers. They're describing an entire toxic culture.
Users demand massive overpays. They get hostile when you offer fair value. The platform begs users for positive reviews while the actual experience remains terrible. Hackers and scammers operate freely alongside aggressive traders who attack anyone not meeting their inflated price expectations.
Account Security Concerns
Multiple users report suspicious account activity. One reviewer shared: "I used this app for 3-4 years since October 2021. There are so many scammers and bots. Pressing one link, and your account goes hacked."
Account bans without explanation appear frequently in reviews. An August 2025 reviewer complained: "My account just got banned for no reason. I have all legit trading reviews in it. I literally lost my account with 100+ reviews."
The Scammer Problem
Scam bots flood the platform. Multiple reviewers from 2025 confirm: "There is a lot of scam bots on Traderie that DM you asking you to check out their channel and say they are giving away free pets."
But here's what makes it worse
Reports don't work. Remember that June 2023 review? "REPORTS ARE NOT HANDLED." Users report scammers with proof. Moderation ignores them. The scammers continue operating.
Review System Manipulation
The review system itself shows concerning patterns. One user discovered: "Half of my reviews are gone including ALL of my 1-star reviews from scammers. I used to have 80 something reviews with 4.5 stars and now I have 5 stars with 41 reviews."
Also Read: How to Get Tralalero Tralala in Plants vs Brainrots
Customer Support Quality: The Reality
Customer support is where Traderie fails most dramatically.
Complete Absence of Response
A verified September 2025 review reveals: "No customer service. They have a 'contact us' link and I submitted it to get help almost 2 months ago. They never got back to me. TODAY I tried submitting the contact form and I got hit with a message saying they only allow 1 submission and I'll have to wait till I get a response."
This isn't isolated. Multiple customers report the exact same experience across different time periods.
Another frustrated user from August 2025 stated: "If you write a ban appeal, don't expect them to reply and surely don't expect them to unban you."
Users lose accounts with hundreds of positive reviews. They submit appeals with evidence. Support never responds. The accounts stay banned permanently.
Report System Failures
When users report scammers or harassers, nothing happens. A May 2025 reviewer explained: "I reported him twice with proof, but got 0 response from moderation. It stated that moderators have reviewed and completed my report twice, but they took no action."
The reporting system exists. But it doesn't function. Scammers continue operating. Legitimate users suffer without recourse.
No Alternative Contact Methods
The platform provides no phone support. No live chat. No alternative email. Just the broken contact form that doesn't generate responses.
Here's what "support" means at Traderie: It doesn't exist. The contact form is decoration. The report system is theater. You're trading on a platform where problems have no solutions.
FAQ Section
Is Traderie a scam?
Traderie itself isn't a scam, it's a legitimate peer-to-peer platform. But it's flooded with scammers who exploit the system. Since Traderie doesn't handle actual trades and provides zero customer support, you have no protection when scams happen.
Does Traderie have customer support?
Trustpilot reviews from 2023 to 2025 confirm Traderie's support is non-existent. Users wait months without responses. The platform limits you to one support ticket that will never get answered.
Can I get my Traderie account back if I'm banned?
Users report submitting ban appeals with proof, but support never responds. Even accounts with 200+ positive reviews get permanently banned without explanation.
Are Traderie reviews trustworthy?
No. Users can leave fake reviews without completing trades. Reviews mysteriously disappear. One user lost ALL their 1-star reviews from scammers while half their total reviews vanished. Scammers build fake positive reviews before exploiting victims.
Does Traderie protect me from scammers?
No. Traderie only connects users, it doesn't control trades. Reports go unhandled.
What's better than Traderie for MM2 trading?
BloxSwaps. It's an automated MM2 trading bot with instant trades, fair values, and zero scammer risk. No coordinating with strangers. No waiting. No manipulation.
Final Verdict: Should You Use Traderie?
Traderie operates as a functioning marketplace. It connects traders. It exists.
But functioning and reliable are different concepts.
The harsh reality:
- Zero customer support (confirmed by Trustpilot reviews across multiple years)
- Technical glitches that persist without fixes
- Account bans with no appeals process
- Review system manipulation without consequences
Here's what bothers us most: Traderie creates the appearance of safety through moderation and reviews. Then it abandons users when those systems fail. You can't reach support. You can't appeal decisions. You can't get help when scammers strike.
For Murder Mystery 2 traders, there's a better option
BloxSwaps is an automated MM2 trading bot that eliminates the peer-to-peer nightmare. No coordinating with strangers. No waiting for unreliable users. No scammer risk. Just instant automated trades with fair values.
